Trip Helpers : What To Take

Spending a long time away from home means that what you pack and take with you has to be thought about carefully. Ironically, anything of personal or monetary value (i.e. home comforts) are best left behind for security reasons.  Only the minimum can go in your bags, so here we decide what are the lucky items that are to join you on your travels.

The Luggage OptionsWhich Clothes To Pack?Which Accessories To Pack?Advice For Spectacle Wearers

The Luggage Options

Before we decide what to take with us, we need to decide what luggage we are going to take. So unless you are a veteran trekker, it may be time to replace the ageing case under the bed, alternatively, maybe the designer bags have to be replaced with a more rugged counterpart.  Either way, as a durable, comfortable  and  occasional seat providing item, your travel bag  is an absolute essential, so let's consider the options:

Option 1 : The rucksack.
Option 2: The rucksack with combined day-pack.
Option 3: The rucksack with wheels.
Option 4: The hold-all \ case with wheels.
Option 5: The cargo bag. 
 
Option 1: The rucksack Good Points Bad Points
rucksack

Option 1: The rucksack.

  • Keeps your hands free.
     
  • Handles obscure terrain. i.e. If you need to get off a boat and onto a sandy beach then a rucksack is perfect : feet may get wet, backpack will not and there's no wheels to get bogged in the sand.
     
  • Provides an even distribution of the weight which puts less strain on a single point of the body. Which basically means you can carry more for longer when compared with a bag with a traditional shoulder strap.
  • Many traditional varieties still provide the main point of access via the top.  i.e. Everything goes in via the top and if you want something at the bottom of the rucksack, then everything comes out via the top. However, more modern rucksacks now provide zip access via the middle. So you can access your belongs just like a suitcase.
     
  • Not as secure or durable as a suitcase with a hard surface.
     
  •  No wheels for pulling along the ground.
Option 2: The rucksack with combined day-pack Good Points Bad Points
rucksack with daypack

Option 2: The rucksack with combined day-pack.

  •  You can of course remove the day-pack and wear it, as most people do, by attaching it to your chest. This way you have a perfectly good rucksack, and (depending on the brand) a perfectly good day-pack. If the day-pack is of good quality and the 2-bags-for-1 price is right, then this becomes a good option.
  • Despite seeming like a good idea, the whole balance and weight distribution benefits found with a normal rucksack go out the window when you attach a day pack to the back of it. Freedom and mobility are lost because the extra bit of weight in the day pack tips the scales, but not in your favour. The day pack is further away from your body's centre of gravity, so it takes less for you to loose your balance.  Not good.
     
  • The day-pack attached to a rucksack is quite poor from a personal safety point of view. Because the day-pack is attached to the rucksack and not to your body, it becomes difficult to have "bag awareness" .  If you were in a crowd would you be able to tell if someone was trying to tamper or access this bag? And this is your day-pack, it's were you tend to store your valuables!
     
  • Despite paying more for this type of bag (because you get 2 bags for 1 in essence) the quality of the day-pack is rarely as good as if bought separately.
     
  • Narrow corridors, train aisles and alike can be problematic with a standard rucksack. The extra width supplied with a day-pack bolted on just doesn't help in those situations.
Option 3: The rucksack with wheels Good Points Bad Points
rucksack with wheels

Option 3: The rucksack with wheels.

  •  Great on smooth surfaces.
     
  • Nice to use as a rucksack when your environment requires.
     
  • The wheels and surrounding plastic moulding add to the weight. This is fine when it's on the ground, but when in rucksack mode any extra weight is never good.
     
  • Despite having rucksack straps, they don't appear  with the same quality and padding as those found purely on a rucksack. Similarly, the wheels might not be as robust as those found only on cases. I fear that this could be a jack of all trades, but master of none.

Option 4: The hold-all with wheels Good Points Bad Points
hold-all

Option 4: The hold-all with wheels.

  •  Great on smooth surfaces.
     
  • Easy access to your belongings.
     
  • If you need to carry your bag for a prolonged amount of time then the lone shoulder strap isn't as comfortable as rucksack straps.
Option 5: The cargo bag. Good Points Bad Points
cargo bag

Option 5: The cargo bag.

  •  Nice to use as a rucksack when needed.
     
  • Easy access to your belongings.
  •  No wheels for pulling along the ground.
     
  • Despite having rucksack straps, they don't appear with the same quality and padding as those found purely on a rucksack.


And the winner is...

The Bottom Line :
Choose a rucksack. If you want to know why then continue reading.

There are quite clearly two categories : bags with wheels and bags without wheels. Having the option to use  wheels and  the ability to be worn on your back seems like a win-win situation. At the airport :  use wheels . Getting off a boat :  stick it on your back. However, this design (option 3 from above) just isn't quite good enough because the wheels and handle add extra weight and reduce comfort when it's used like a rucksack. I want my cake and to eat it. I want a rucksack with wheels that I can hardly tell are there. I'm sure with time this design will get much better, but I wouldn't risk using it just yet.

Now with option 3 removed, we are left to choose if we want a bag with wheels or not. On a round the world trip there will be times when having a wheels-only case will be awkward. It could be fine for 80% of the trip, but not for the entirety. However, if you are considering 3 weeks across a developed country, then having a wheeled variety case is likely to be ideal.

But we are planning for a round the world trip, so a rucksack is best suited. It may be an obvious winner, but there are reasons why the masses use a rucksack. The rucksacks good points mentioned above are key to surviving a round the world trip.

The only situation in which the standard hold-all triumphs is by having a pair of wheels. But the world is not smooth and flat, so you are better off with a rucksack. And most airports and many train stations have trolleys, so if your ruck sack does get too much, you can always throw it on a trolley. 

Accessing the contents of a rucksack can be considered awkward too, but modern designs provide access to the innards via a zip in the middle of the bag. This is great and makes it just as easy as a regular bag to find your belongings - I'd have to insist on having this variety of rucksack.

The durability of a rucksack may be questioned? But this too can be overcome as additional protector bags can be purchased.  They act as a kind of sack (many people actually use farmers' sacks)  for your rucksack and prevent straps from getting ripped off and other damage when going through airports. 

So, considering the above add-ons and improvements, the rucksacks negative points are wiped out. Hence we have a winner, the people's choice: the rucksack. 

Buyers Tip :
If you can, don't buy a rucksack online, buy it from your local outdoors store. Why? Well it really makes a difference being able to try a rucksack on. You may have all sorts of ideas of what you want, but it's the fit that has to be right. Many packs have complicated ergonomic back support systems. Some are too complicated and offer too many fitting options when all you want is to adjust and go. You may find a simpler, cheaper model that fits you perfect. Try a few on, adjust them,  maybe you have a long \ short \ wide back and brand X is better suited? Rucksack sizes vary and are measured in litres, but there's no conversion chart for clothes carried to litres, so at least this way you get idea of what size to get and what size you can carry. Hopefully you'll "bag" a bargain and there will be no hidden surprises, plus it really gets you in the trekking mood and is a lot more fun than just clicking a "buy me" button.